Circumstances Considered: Wife's Demand For Independent Stay Not Always Cruelty: Jharkhand HC

The court made the ruling while examining allegations of cruelty arising from a demand for separate residence.

Wife's Demand For Independent Stay Edited by
Circumstances Considered: Wife's Demand For Independent Stay Not Always Cruelty: Jharkhand HC

Circumstances Considered: Wife's Demand For Independent Stay Not Always Cruelty: Jharkhand HC

The Jharkhand High Court recently observed that a spouse’s preference for independent accommodation cannot automatically be treated as matrimonial cruelty.

The court made the ruling while examining allegations of cruelty arising from a demand for separate residence. Earlier, a Delhi High court order had stated that a wife persistently pressuring her husband to sever his bond with his family certainly amounted to cruelty.

Read Also: Wife Pressuring Husband To Separate From Family Is Cruelty, Ground For Divorce: Delhi HC

The Jharkhand high court pointed out that courts must consider the surrounding circumstances, the needs of the parties, their obligations towards dependent family members and the manner in which the demand was made.

The case arose from husband’s petition that his wife refused to live in a joint family and had objected to the presence of his deceased sister’s three children, who were residing with him.

Read Also: Wife Can’t File Cruelty Case Against Husband’s Girlfriend; Karnataka HC Says She Is Not His Relative

The husband alleged that his wife had pressured him to send his elderly and ailing father to their native place and had subjected him to mental and physical harassment.

Hearing the case, a Division Bench of Justice Sujit Narayan Prasad and Justice Pradeep Kumar Srivastava upheld the dismissal of a husband’s divorce petition, holding that the Family Court’s judgment rejecting his claims of cruelty and desertion did not warrant interference.